In an increasingly competitive business context, where creativity and innovation are key drivers of growth, it is essential to understand how rights to intellectual works and creations are managed within the employment relationship. What happens when an employee creates an intellectual work as part of their job? Who owns the rights to that work? In this article, we will delve into the legal implications of the intellectual property of salaried employees in Spain, according to the Intellectual Property Law (IPL).
Who owns the exploitation rights?
Article 51 of the Law on Intellectual Property establishes that, unless otherwise agreed, the exploitation rights over works created by an employee within the framework of his or her work duties belong to the employer. This means that, if an employee develops software, a graphic design or writes a report that has intellectual value during his working hours and under his contracted functions, the company is the owner of the exploitation rights over that work.
However, this principle should not be understood as a total transfer of rights. The moral rights of the author, which include the right to be recognised as the creator of the work and the right to demand respect for the integrity of the work, are unwaivable and always remain in the hands of the employee.
This creates an interesting balance: while the company has the right to economically exploit the creation (sell it, modify it, distribute it, etc.), the worker retains intellectual paternity over the work, which ensures his recognition and protects his reputation as a creator.
Collaborative works: what happens to rights?
In addition to individual creations, many companies produce what are known as collective or collaborative works. These are creations in which several employees contribute their work.
In these cases, the IPL indicates that the exploitation rights also belong to the employer, who has managed and financed the creative process. However, each author retains his or her moral rights over the parts he or she has created. In collaborative works, it is common for specific contractual clauses to be established to regulate both the economic exploitation of the work and the recognition of the authors, which ensures that the individual effort is properly valued.
What does the case law say?
Case law in Spain has reinforced this dual approach between the exploitation rights and the moral rights of the employee. The courts have made it clear that, although companies have the right to exploit works created under an employment relationship, this does not eliminate the employee’s right to be recognised as the author. Moreover, in several cases, it has been stressed that the assignment of exploitation rights must be explicit and well regulated in employment contracts.
One of the critical points that has emerged in several judgments is the importance of companies detailing in their employment contracts the assignment of exploitation rights. In the absence of such clauses, the employee could claim part of the economic rights, especially if the creation was made outside the strict scope of his or her work duties.
The role of contracts: the key to avoiding conflict
Since the area of intellectual property in paid work can lead to conflicts between employees and employers, it is crucial that companies draw up clear employment contracts that regulate the ownership of exploitation rights. In these agreements, it should be specified in detail whether and under what conditions creations made by employees in the course of their work will be owned by the employer.
A well-drafted contract not only protects the interests of the company, but can also provide legal certainty for the employee, who will know exactly what to expect in relation to the rights to his or her work.
Final reflection: a balance between rights and obligations
The intellectual property of the employee is an issue that is close to the hearts of both employees and employers. On the one hand, workers have the right to have their work recognised and respected. On the other hand, companies have a legitimate interest in protecting their investments and securing exploitation rights over the creations they finance.
To avoid misunderstandings or disputes, the key is to establish clear agreements from the outset. A good contract regulating intellectual property can be the best guarantee for both parties, ensuring that companies can commercially exploit their employees’ creations and that employees, in turn, see their contribution recognised.
In conclusion, the Intellectual Property Law provides a balanced framework, but it needs to be complemented by detailed contractual arrangements that are adapted to the realities of each sector and type of company.
This publication does not constitute legal advice.
_____
How can we help you from LAW4DIGITAL?
At LAW4DIGITAL we are lawyers specialized in digital businesses. We provide comprehensive legal advice to digital companies. We help you with online legal advice.
We will keep you updated on digital business. In any case, you can contact us by mail addressed to hola@law4digital.comby calling (+34) 931 444 820 or by filling out our form at law4digital.com.
We are waiting for you in the next post!
Law4Digital team.